Brains here, brains there
#Tech bay
09.29.2025 Reading time: 7 minutes
BizkaiaTech editorial team
Illustration: Paula Guerrero
It doesn’t matter when you turn on the TV: for years now, the news has been talking about the brain drain (sometimes referred to as “talent drain” or “human capital flight”). But what does that even mean? Brain drain is the emigration of professionals and scientists with a university education in their home country to other nations. Young people who, upon finishing university, head abroad in search of new experiences; experienced workers who move to chase more promising economic opportunities; or simply people who want a new life somewhere their work and effort are valued. Cases of all kinds. And even if it doesn’t seem like it, each and every one of them is concerning.
WHY SHOULD I CARE?
You might think it’s not that big a deal that everyone has the right to look for a new life. And that’s true, no one’s denying it. But there’s a reason why the news makes such a fuss about this: because it’s harmful, not just for us but for any region. While there are different types of human capital flight (for example, organizational, when a worker changes from one company to another; or industrial, when they change not just companies but industries as well), here we’ll focus on geographic brain drain: the kind that happens when skilled workers leave their country or region of residence to seek better job opportunities elsewhere.
Let’s first look at some of the causes behind this type of migration:
- The conditions offered by companies: If workers aren’t happy with the conditions offered at home, they’re more likely to look abroad. Let’s break it down: when it comes to wages, Spain ranks 15th among the 29 countries analyzed, with an average of €18.2 per hour (Bankinter, 2024). The top spots are taken by Luxembourg, Denmark, Norway, and Finland, with hourly wages between €39–47. If we compare the Basque Country with the rest of Spain, however, we find an average of €33,504/year, making it the best-paid autonomous community in the country (20 Minutos, 2025). Remote work is another factor people value more since COVID-19. Eurostat notes that nationally, only 7.1% of workers in Spain work from home, compared with 21.7% in Finland, 21.4% in Ireland, and 14.3% in Belgium and Switzerland. Surprising, right?
- The economic and social situation where people live: Housing prices, financial aid, the welfare state, unemployment or underemployment rates, and taxes are all factors people weigh when deciding where to live and work. Another key factor is investment in R&D. If researchers and scientists find better opportunities and resources abroad, allowing them to advance their careers and contribute more to their fields, they often head that way.
- Ambition and work climate: The drive to grow professionally, not just through promotions but through recognition and learning, is another common hurdle for talented people. Combine that with the work environment at their jobs, and the decision to move abroad can become inevitable. In fact, according to Business Insider (2024), “Spain is one of the European countries with the worst results in employee engagement, job satisfaction, and levels of anger, stress, and sadness at work.”
And as we know, every cause comes with its consequences. Here are a few that brain drain can bring:
- Economic and social impact: The lack of qualified talent can make companies less competitive, especially in scientific, technological, and engineering fields, which affects the local economy. What’s more, when companies can’t find the right profiles, they often shuffle their staff around, creating uncertainty for workers and lowering productivity. Taken together, this can worsen services in both public and private sectors, reducing quality of life.
- Loss of investment in education: When countries (or regions) invest in education but graduates leave afterward, that investment doesn’t translate into economic growth. This can eventually push public and private institutions to cut back on education spending.
BISCAY, THE PLACE TO BE
But it’s not all doom and gloom. We live in Biscay, think about it! According to the FADSP (Federation of Associations for the Defense of Public Healthcare, 2024), the public health system (in the autonomous community) is among the best in the country. Investment in R&D is on the rise, at 2.16% of Euskadi’s GDP and closing in on the EU-27 average of 2.27% in 2022 (Basque Government, 2025). Economically, Biscay has surpassed pre-COVID performance levels: “SMEs in Biscay have advanced in innovation. The business fabric is well-positioned in innovative activities, particularly product innovation. There’s also strong entrepreneurship, especially innovative entrepreneurship” (Government of Biscay, 2024). The same report highlights improved qualification and employment rates compared to 2019, as well as the increasing education levels of young people entering the workforce. On top of that, thanks to the tireless efforts of Bizkaia Talent (you’ll get to know more about their work in the following pages), the mission to attract, retain, and connect talent never stops.
Overall, a periodic sociological study by the Government of Biscay (2024) shows that citizens rate quality of life in the region very highly: 7.7 out of 10. And 64% of respondents say they are very optimistic about Biscay’s future.
And even though we’ve already given plenty of reasons to stay here, we might have forgotten the most important one: in Madrid, you’ll pay €5 for a pintxo de tortilla, and in Norway, you won’t even be able to get your hands on one. So yeah, think about it…
So, if we want the news to stop repeating itself and actually bring us something new, maybe we all need to do our part, not just skilled workers, but companies and industries too. Because we all know our region is full of people with good heads on their shoulders. And don’t forget about the pintxos… they are quite important as well.
Labels
- #cultura
- #emprendimiento
- #innovación
- #ciencia
- #estrategia
- #futuro
- #educación
- #tecnólogas
- #talento
Take our advice and check it out
Slide to show more
Cookies
We use proprietary and third-party cookies for technical, analytical and customisation purposes, such as choosing the language in which to display the website. For more information, please consult our cookies policy (Opens modal window).
Cookies policy
The website at https://www.bizkaia.eus (hereinafter, the Website) uses tools to track browsing activity on the website and the IP address of the service recipient for the purpose of improving and guaranteeing the provision of services or technical operation of the website, distinguishing you from other users and analysing your browsing habits.
This Cookies Policy seeks to inform you clearly and precisely about the operation and function of the cookies we use.
What are cookies and why do we use them?
A cookie is a file that is downloaded to your computer when accessing certain websites.
Cookies enable a website to, among other things, store and recover information about the browsing habits of a user or their device and, depending on the information contained and the way in which the same is used by the device, may be used to recognise the user.
Current law allows us to store cookies on your device if they are strictly necessary for operation of this website. However, we need permission for all other cookies.
Types of cookies based on the managing entity
Depending on who manages the computer or domain from where the cookies are sent and who processes the data obtained, a distinction can be made between the following types of cookies:
- Proprietary cookies: these are managed by the Provincial Council of Biscay.
-
Third-party cookies: these are managed by another entity, which processes the data obtained via the cookies.
This website may contain cookies belonging to the Basque Government, used for its own purposes and stored by domains other than those owned by the Bizkaia Provincial Council.
Types of cookies based on their purpose
- Technical cookies: these allow the user to browse a website, platform or application and to use the various options or services available, such as control data traffic and communication, identify the session, access restricted areas, request registration or participation in an event, use security elements while browsing, store content for video or audio playback, or share content via social media networks.
- Customisation cookies: these allow the user to access the service with some general characteristics predefined according to a series of criteria on the user’s device, such as the language, type of browser being used to access the service, regional configuration from where the service is accessed, etc.
- Analysis cookies: these allow the number of users to be counted and the browsing activity to be statistically measured and analysed for the purpose of improving the services made available. They may be proprietary or third-party cookies.
Duration of the cookies
- Session cookies: these collect and store data while the user is visiting a website.
- Persistent cookies: the data are stored on the device in an ongoing fashion and may be accessed and processed during a period defined by the cookie manager, which may range from a few minutes to several years.
Which cookies does this website use?
In each row you can find data relating to Technical cookies
| Name | Purpose | Duration | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| JSESSIONID | Session identifier | Session | Bizkaia Provincial Council |
| ASPSESSIONID | Session identifier | Session | Bizkaia Provincial Council |
| TS01 | Session identifier | Session | Bizkaia Provincial Council |
| LFR_SESSION_STATE | Session identifier | Session | Bizkaia Provincial Council |
| COOKIE_SUPPORT | Indicate whether the user has the cookie support activated | 1 year | Bizkaia Provincial Council |
| pc_tecnicas_bizkaia | Choose your preferences for acceptance of the block of technical cookies | 1 year | Bizkaia Provincial Council |
| pc_analitica_bizkaia | Choose your preferences for acceptance of the block of analytical cookies | 1 year | Bizkaia Provincial Council |
| pc_preferencias_bizkaia | Choose your preferences for acceptance/rejection of the block of preferential cookies | 1 year | Bizkaia Provincial Council |
| pc_terceros_bizkaia | Choose your preferences for acceptance/rejection of the block of third-party cookies | 1 year | Bizkaia Provincial Council |
| Kultursistema_session | Keeping the user’s session | 1 year | Kultursistema |
| CPLB | Contains information used by our load-balancing servers | Session | Provincial Council of Biscay |
| XSRF-TOKEN | To prevent CSRF (Cross-Site Request Forgery) attacks | 1 year | Kultursistema |
| _GRECAPTCHA | Protects the website from spam and brute-force attacks | 5 months |
In each row you can find data relating to Analysis cookies
| Name | Purpose | Duration | Owner | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| dtCookie | Track a visit through multiple requests | Session | Bizkaia Provincial Council | |
| dtLatC | Measure the latency of the server to monitor performance | Session | Bizkaia Provincial Council | |
| dtPC | Necessary to identify the appropriate parameters for beacon transmission; includes session ID for correlation | Session | Bizkaia Provincial Council | |
| dtSa | Intermediate storage for actions spanning pages | Session | Bizkaia Provincial Council | |
| rxVisitor | Visitor ID to correlate sessions | Constantly | Bizkaia Provincial Council | |
| rxvt | Session waiting time | Session | Bizkaia Provincial Council | |
| iyrc-user-id | Distinguish users | 1 year | Bizkaia Provincial Council | |
| _ga, _ga_XXXXXXXXXXX | Analysis | To distinguish users | 2 years | Google Analytics |
| _gat, _gat_XXXXXXXXXXX | Analysis | To limit the percentage of requests | 1 minute | Google Analytics |
| _gid | Analysis | To distinguish users | 1 day | Google Analytics |
In each row you can find data relating to Personalisation cookies
| Name | Purpose | Duration | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Idioma | Select the language preferred by the user | 1 year | Bizkaia Provincial Council |
| cookie-tramites-favs | Save favourite procedures in Prior Appointment | 1 year | Bizkaia Provincial Council |
In each row you can find data relating to Third-party cookies
| Name | Purpose | Duration | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| CLID | Identify a user’s first visit | 1 year | Microsoft Clarity |
| APISID | Store user preferences and information during page views with Google maps in them. | 2 years | |
| HSID | Store user preferences and information during page views with Google maps in them. | 2 years | |
| MUID | Store user preferences and information during page views with Google maps in them. | 1 year | Microsoft Clarity |
| NID | Remember their preferences and other information | 6 months | |
| SAPISID | Show personalised advertisements on Google sites | 2 years | |
| SID | Provide advertisement delivery or retargeting, provide fraud prevention. | 2 years | |
| SIDCC | Provide reliable web traffic identification. | 1 year | |
| SM | Used to synchronise the MUID between Microsoft domains. | Session | Microsoft Clarity |
| SSID | Provide advertisement delivery or retargeting, provide fraud prevention. | 2 years | |
| __Secure-1PAPISID | Create a website visitor interest profile to show relevant and personalised Google advertising. | 2 years | |
| __Secure-1PSID | Create a website visitor interest profile to show relevant and personalised Google advertising. | 2 years | |
| __Secure-1PSIDCC | Create a website visitor interest profile to show relevant and personalised advertising through retargeting. | 1 year | |
| __Secure-1PSIDTS | Create a website visitor interest profile to show relevant and personalised advertising through retargeting. | 1 year | |
| __Secure-3PSID | 2 years | ||
| __Secure-3PSIDCC | Create a website visitor interest profile to show relevant and personalised advertising through retargeting. | 1 year | |
| __Secure-3PSIDTS | Create a website visitor interest profile to show relevant and personalised advertising through retargeting. | 1 year | |
| __Secure-ENID | Necessary cookies to use website services and options | 1 year | |
| ar_debug | Refine advertisements. | 1 año | |
| MR | Indicate when MUID is refreshed | 6 months | Microsoft Clarity |
| XSRF-TOKEN | Indicate when MUID is refreshed | 1 hour | Kultursistema |
| _fbp | Store and track website visits | 1 year | |
| kultursistema_session | Keep the user’s session | 1 hour | Kultursistema |
| AEC | Detect spam, fraud, and abuse | 6 months | |
| SOCS | Store user cookies preferences | 13 months | |
| Locale | not available | Basque government | |
| _hegoa_coop_session | Create a session ID for users | Session | Basque government |
How to deactivate or delete cookies?
When first accessing the Website, the user may configure and accept or reject the cookies on this Website. Subsequently, the user may change or withdraw their consent at any time via this Cookies Policy or the settings page.
However, you may exercise your right to freely deactivate them and even delete the cookies on this Website at any time. This is done differently depending on which browser you are using. Here is a quick guide for the most popular browsers.
- Deactivate Cookies in Chrome
- Deactivate Cookies in Explorer
- Deactivate Cookies in Firefox
- Deactivate Cookies in Safari
- Deactivate Cookies in Edge
If you deactivate or delete cookies, certain features of the Website may no longer function correctly.
Changes to the Cookies Policy
The Website reserves the right to change this Cookies Policy under the terms provided for by current legislation. We therefore recommend that you revise this policy each time you access our website to see any changes and read the pertinent information.
Configure cookies
We show you hereinbelow the different categories of cookies that our web page uses. You can personalise your choice by accepting or rejecting these categories through the buttons enabled to that end. For more information, consult our cookies policy (Opens modal window).
-
Technical Always active
These are needed to allow browsing on our website and for basic tasks related to correct website operation.
